Notes & Commentary:
Ver. 1. Ox.
By this name all bulls, cows, &c., are designated. For it was not lawful to sacrifice any thing which had lost any member,
Exodus xii. 5., and Leviticus i. 3.
Ver. 2. Covenant,
by incurring the evil of idolatry. (Calmet) (Hebrews x. 29.)
Ver. 3. The
host of heaven. That is, the stars. (Challoner) --- This species of idolatry was the most ancient and common in the East.
Job (xxxi. 26, 28) takes notice of the adoration of the sun and of the moon, and calls it a very great iniquity, and a
denial against the most high God. He lived in Arabia, and probably not far from the place where Moses was addressing the
Israelites. (Haydock) --- The pagans looked upon the sun and moon as the king and queen of heaven, and the stars as their
guards. Plato says (in Phædro) that "the sun marches at the head of the gods, in a winged chariot, and the eleven other gods
lead on their bands of demons," or the stars, &c.
Ver. 5. Stoned,
not far from the gates, where they received sentence. Thus the sabbath-breaker was stoned without the camp, (Numbers
xv. 35,) and St. Stephen out of the city of Jerusalem, Acts vii. 57. When only a few were concerned, the twenty-three judges
passed sentence: but if a whole tribe had been guilty, the cognizance of the affair was left to the Sanhedrim. When a city
was infected with this abomination, it was wholly destroyed. But no one was punished, except two witnesses (ver. 6,) attested
that formal idolatry, by sacrifice, &c., had been committed. (Selden, Syned. iii. 4.)
Ver. 6. Slain.
When the action was public, this formality was not requisite, chap. xiii. 9. --- Him. One witness was never admitted
to prove any crime; neither would the Jews receive for witnesses, women, infants under thirteen, slaves, publicans, thieves,
&c. (Josephus, [Antiquities?] iv. last chapter.) The Rabbins also reject other notorious offenders, enemies, relations,
and those who had not a competent knowledge of the law, &c. (Ap. Selden, Syn. ii. 13. 11.; and Grotius) --- But we could
wish for some authors of more credit. (Calmet)
Ver. 7. Kill
him. Thus testifying that they approve the sentence, and are willing that his blood should be required at their hands,
if they had accused him falsely. The criminal was hurled down a precipice by one of the witnesses, and, if he survived, he
was stoned by the other, and by the whole people. Maimonides asserts, that the execution took place on some great festival,
for the terror and instruction of the multitude; but others call this in question. (Fagius) (Calmet)
Ver. 8. If
thou perceive, &c. Here we see what authority God was pleased to give to the church-guides of the Old Testament, in
deciding, without appeal, all controversies relating to the law; promising that they should not err therein; and punishing
with death such as proudly refused to obey their decisions: and surely he has not done less for the church-guides of the New
Testament. (Challoner) --- Hard. Hebrew also means, "doubtful, hidden, divided;" so that the opinions of the judges
do not agree. In matters of fact, the thing is more easily investigated on the spot. But in these cases, where the law is
ambiguous, as even the divine ordinances frequently are, being delivered in human language, (Grotius) a living judge is necessary.
God remits the Jews in the council of the priests, at the head of whom was the sovereign pontiff, who was the natural and
supreme judge of such difficulties, ver. 9, 12. (Haydock) --- And blood, to decide when murder must be punished with
death, and when the right of an asylum may be claimed. (Calmet) --- The Vulgate renders the same words, 2 Paralipomenon xix.
10. --- Between kindred and kindred, as the different degrees cause many embarrassments, with regard to marriages,
&c. (Tirinus) --- The Rabbins understand that the judge had to declare when a woman was rendered unclean, Leviticus xii.
4. (Lyranus) --- And cause, or lawsuit; some thinking that a greater sum for reparation of an injury should be required,
others judging that one of the contending parties should be set at liberty, while the other judges are of a contrary sentiment.
Hebrew, "between judgment and judgment," when a doubt arises whether laymen or the Levites may be the proper judges. The Rabbins
only remit three cases to the tribunal of the latter, respecting, 1. The red heifer; 2. the woman accused of
adultery by her jealous husband; 3. the heifer to be offered in sacrifice, for a murder committed by a person unknown,
chap. xxi. 5. --- And leprosy. Various difficulties might arise concerning this matter, of which the priests had to
pass sentence, Leviticus xiii. Some render the Hebrew negah, "wound." The law of retaliation required a scrupulous
nicety. Blood, cause, and leprosy, may denote lawsuits of a criminal, less important, and ceremonial nature. (Jansenius)
--- Vary. Hebrew, "which are matters of contention within thy gates."
Ver. 9. Judge.
Moses does not specify whether the contending parties, or the judges themselves thought proper to have the matter debated
before a higher court. The Rabbins observe, that appeals to the Sanhedrim were only the last resort, and that the sentence
of that tribunal was to be complied with under pain of death, ver. 12. (Selden, Syned. iii. 2. 2.) The judge here mentioned,
according to them and the generality of commentators, after Josephus, Philo, &c., is no other than the high priest, as
the Scripture plainly indicates, chap. xxi. 5., and Ezechiel xliv. 24. He abode near the tabernacle, and God enabled him to
explain the law, when he was arrayed with the ephod, and the Urim and Thummim. Some moderns, who have an interest to lessen
the authority of the ecclesiastical jurisdiction, with Calvin, Ainsworth, &c., pretend that an appeal was to be made to
the priests, in disputes which concerned religion, and to the civil magistrate in other cases, 2 Paralipomenon xix. 5. (Calmet)
--- But an appeal to the high priest, in doubtful cases, could not be denied. The government of the Jews was a theocracy,
and the pontiff acted as the vicegerent of God. (Haydock)
Ver. 10. Preside.
The high priests who are to succeed each other. (Worthington)
Ver. 11. According,
&c. This law was to be the rule of the priests, in passing sentence. It was not left to the judgment of individuals to
comply or not, according as they might explain the law for themselves. Such a proceeding would be nugatory, as they would
thus be themselves the ultimate judges of their own cause. (Haydock) --- They shall seek the law at his (the priest's)
mouth, Malachias ii. 7. Protestants make, therefore, a very frivolous restriction, when they allow his sentence to
bind only "so long as he is the true minister of God, and pronounceth according to his word." (Bible, 1603.) (Worthington)
--- If any had been proud enough among the Jews, to persuade himself that he understood the law better than the high priest,
he would not on that account have escaped death. (Haydock) --- The authority of the Christian Church is not inferior to that
of the Synagogue, only, "instead of death, excommunication is now inflicted" on the rebellious. (St. Gregory, Matthew xviii.
17.; St. Augustine, q. 38.) In effect, St. Paul assures us that the priests of the law, serve unto the example and shadow
of heavenly things. But now he (Christ)...is the mediator of the better covenant, which is established on better promises,
Hebrews viii. 5, 6. If therefore the privilege of deciding points of faith and morality, without danger of mistake, was granted
to the synagogue, can any one doubt but that Christ would provide as ample a security for his Church, with which he has promised
to remain for ever, and with his Holy Spirit to teach her all the truth? (Haydock) ---
St. Augustine dwells upon this argument (Doct. 4.) and proves the infallibility both of the Jewish and of the Christian Church.
Hence Christ said, with respect to the former, which was not yet rejected, All therefore whatsoever they shall say to you,
observe and do: but according to their works, do ye not: for they say the truth, and do not practise what they
require of others. If the heads of the Catholic Church should be equally immoral, their true doctrine must not therefore be
despised, lest Christ and his Father be at the same time despised. For this is the express admonition of our heavenly
lawgiver, hear the Church: (Matthew xvii. 17,) and this he does not require without giving us a full assurance, that
we may do it without fear of being led astray. The sole command of God implies as much, if he had said no more. For can he
order us to sin? The pretended reformers, who blushed not to make this blasphemous assertion, might easily swallow down the
other, respecting the defection and fallibility of the whole Church; and might even believe, that the whole world had been
drowned in abominable idolatry for eight hundred years and more. (Hom. on the peril of idolat. p. 3.) How much more
they do not determine, lest they should be forced to tell when the religion of the Catholics began, and that they will never
do without dating from Christ and the apostles, the foundations of the only true Church. (Haydock) --- The Jews had such a
respect for the decisions of their Rabbins, in consequence of this command of God, that some hesitate not to assert, that
if one of them should declare that the left hand was the right, they would believe him; and they condemn the refractory to
most grievous torments in hell. (Buxtorf., Syn. i.) --- We must shew the most profound submission to the decrees of the Church.
(Calmet) --- Yet we are not bound to assent to the decisions of every teacher. Only, when the Church speaks, we must not refuse
to obey, nor pretend to appoint ourselves judges of what she teaches. A private doctor, however eminent, may fall into some
absurdities, but the major part of the pastors of the Church, with the Pope at their head, never can. In vain have the records
of nineteen centuries been ransacked, to find a single instance of such a general agreement in error. If the Synagogue passed
a wicked sentence upon Jesus Christ, we must reflect that the forms here required (ver. 8,) were neglected; and it was then
expiring, and giving place to a better covenant, as the prophets had foretold. Yet even in that sentence, which
was so unjust on the part of Caiphas, St. John (xi. 51.) acknowledges the truth of God. And this he spoke not of himself:
but being the high priest, that year, he prophesied that Jesus should die for the nation, and not only for the nation, but
to gather together in one the children of God that were dispersed. The Synagogue could claim submission no longer, after
the great prophet had come to abrogate the law of fear, and to substitute that of love. Hence while he was there to teach
himself, (Hebrews i. 2,) there was no danger of deception for the people. But the covenant which he has established is to
last for ever: no prophet or lawgiver is promised to introduce any change, or greater perfection, so that no one can plead
for an excuse of his rebellion, that the Church may deceive and pass an erroneous judgment; or, if he do, he must be cut off
from the society of the faithful, by the spiritual sword; and, dying in that state, without the Church for his mother, he
need never expect that God will acknowledge him for his son. See St. Cyprian, Unity of the Catholic Church. If an individual
pastor should pass such a perverse sentence, the case would be very different. Yet, even in such trying cases, an humble conduct
will be the best security and proof of innocence, and God will reward those who have suffered unjustly. (Haydock)
Ver. 12. And
the decree. Some copies read with Sixtus V ex decreto, by &c., "decree," (Haydock) as if a lay-judge stood
ready to put the sentence in execution. (Calmet) --- But there was no necessity of any farther judgment after the high priest
had spoken, who is here declared the sovereign judge. (St. Cyprian, ep. 55.) Hebrew, "or to the judge." Amama ridicules
his friend, Ant. a Dominis, for saying that the Hebrew and Vulgate have et decreto. (Haydock) --- The Rabbins inform
us, that if any judge refused to acquiesce in the decision, and endeavoured to draw others into his opinion, in matters of
consequence, (as those are where the guilty is ordered to be cut off,) he was to be strangled, on a festival day, at Jerusalem,
that all the people hearing it might fear, ver. 13. (Selden, Syned. iii. 3.) (Calmet)
Ver. 13. Pride.
Hebrew, "do presumptuously," as the Protestants translate. How will they excuse their leaders, Luther, &c., and themselves,
from this grievous charge? If the person, who presumed to assert that the leprosy had not infected some one, whom the priests
condemned, (ver. 8,) could not escape death, shall we esteem those innocent whom the whole Church rejects? Hic niger est,
hunc tu Romane caveto. (Horace) (Haydock)
Ver. 14. King.
The Rabbins observe, that one was to be elected before the place for the temple was fixed upon, that the tribes might not
contend about that honour. (Grotius) --- God foresees that the people will insist upon having a king, and gives his consent,
reserving to himself the choice, and appointing laws for him, that he may not forget that he is only the lieutenant of
the most high. Yet God testified his displeasure, when the Israelites demanded a king, because they did it in a seditious
manner, so as to reject the prophet Samuel, whom he had given them for a ruler, in whom they could discover no fault. (Calmet)
(1 Kings viii. 7., and x. 19.)
Ver. 15. Choose,
as he did Saul, David, and Solomon, who succeeded to the throne of his father, though he was not the eldest son. (Menochius)
--- Then the throne began to be hereditary, in virtue of God's promise to David. (Calmet) --- Brother. The Jews neglected
this law, when they willingly recognized the authority of Herod, two years after the birth of Christ. See Genesis xlix. 10.
(Haydock) --- A stranger might attempt to draw off the people from the service of the true God, and mutual love would not
so easily subsist between them. (Menochius)
Ver. 16. Horses.
Josue and David rendered the captured horses useless, (Josue xi. 6., and 2 Kings viii. 4,) and the judges rode on asses, Judges
x. 4., and xii. 14. Solomon began to keep some, and in his days Egypt was noted for the traffic of horses; though, after Sesostris
had intersected the country with canals, they were more neglected. (Marsham, Canon. sæc. xiii., and xiv.) God did not wish
his people to engage in the tumults of war, nor would he permit their king to be puffed up with his own strength, Psalm xix.
8., and xxxii. 17. Philo says he would not have them to listen to any who might promise to conduct them to a better country,
and thus teach them to lead a wandering life. (Calmet) --- He precludes also the attempt to conquer Egypt. Hebrew, "he shall
not make the people return to Egypt, in order that he may multiply horses," by their buying them for him in that country,
3 Kings x. 29. --- Way. When the people proposed returning, God severely punished them, Numbers xiv. 5.
Ver. 17. Mind,
and reign in his name. Hebrew, "and his heart turn not away" from the worship of the true God, as it happened to Solomon,
and to many other kings, whom Moses seems to have had in view. Too great a number of wives would tend to perplex and enervate
the king, and to eat up the treasures of his people. The Jewish lawyers allow the king only 18, and they say David and Roboam
had that number. But the latter had moreover 60 concubines, (2 Paralipomenon xi. 21,) and Solomon had many more. In effect,
the number seems not to be restricted, and, what is very singular, the Rabbins allow all but the high priest and the king
as many as they can keep, though the sages advise people to have no more than four, which seems to be the sentiment of the
Mahometans. This liberty was taken by the Jews till the emperors restricted them, A.D. 593. (Selden, Uxor. i. 8, &c.)
Plurality of wives was not formerly a sin, though Solomon offended by too great excess. (St. Augustine, q. 27.) (Worthington)
--- Gold. Immense riches are seldom possessed even by kings, without the oppression of their subjects, and great danger
of falling into extravagance. If David amassed so much gold, it was destined for the building of the temple. But Solomon laying
on heavy taxes, alienated the hearts of his people, and gave occasion to the revolt of 10 tribes; and Ezechias brought on
a severe chastisement by making a parade of his treasures to the ambassadors of the king of Babylon, 4 Kings xx. 15. (Calmet)
Ver. 18. Of
this law, perhaps from the 14th verse to the end of the chapter, (Haydock) or the whole Book of Deuteronomy, which contains
an abridgment of the law, (Josue viii. 32.; Menochius) or even the five books, which were formerly written without any division,
and went under the name of the law. (Grotius; &c.) --- Hebrew seems favourable to this last opinion, (Calmet) "he shall
write a copy of this law in a book, out of that which is kept by the priests," unless Moses might only require that he should
have a copy of what he was then delivering. (Haydock) --- Some say that the king was obliged to take two copies, one of which
he was to have always about him. It is not certain whether he was obliged to write himself, as Philo asserts, or another might
do it for him. The diadem and the law were presented to Joas, when he ascended the throne, 2 Paralipomenon xxiii. 11. (Calmet)
--- If (Haydock) Josias had not seen a copy of the law before the 18th year of his reign, this precept must have been very
ill observed, 4 Kings xxii. 11. (Calmet) --- But, very probably, that book, which Helcias discovered in the temple, was the
autograph of Moses, and therefore made a deeper impression upon all who saw and heard it read, than if it had been read than
if it had been only an ordinary copy. This copy might have been mislaid or secreted in those troublesome times; and then the
high priest brought it to light again, he as well as the king and all the people, were filled with joy and amazement. (Haydock)
--- It was the custom of the Jews to present a copy of the law to their kings, when they first sat upon the throne; and hence,
perhaps, they make a similar present to the Pope, when he goes to take possession of the Lateran church. (Morus.) --- They
presented one to Innocent II when he made his entry into Paris, 1146, and another to king Louis the Fat, as Suger informs
us. (Calmet) --- Priests. Temporal princes who desire to become virtuous and wise, will ever take the law of God at
the priest's hands. (Worthington)
Ver. 19. Law.
Pious Christian emperors and kings have esteemed it their greatest glory and happiness to read and meditate on the holy commandments
of God, in order to regulate their conduct, amid the various dangerous occupations of their station. (Haydock) --- Constantine
the Great, Charlemagne, St. Stephen of Hungary, Alphonsus I of Spain, were noted for the zeal which they shewed in this particular.
Alphonsus of Arragon, had read the Bible, with the Commentaries, 14 times over, and the great Alfred wrote all the New Testament
twice over with his own hand. (Calmet) --- He had translated into English Saxon all or most of the Bible before 900, as king
Athelstan did about 925. (Encyclopedia Britannica, Bible, &c.) Yet the Catholic Church never condemned this conduct of
her children, as Protestants would insinuate. (Cath. Doct. by N. G.)
Ver. 20. With
pride. This is not expressed in Hebrew, but it is clearly (Haydock) implied. Humility is the most difficult virtue for
a prince to practice, amid the flattery of his courtiers, and the splendour with which he is environed. See St. Augustine,
City of God v. 24. (Calmet) --- His sons. Wicked kings seldom left a quiet possession of the throne to their heirs.
(Menochius) --- David and his posterity reigned in succession, by an effect of the divine bounty. (Calmet)
Bible Text & Cross-references:
Victims must be without blemish. Idolaters are to be slain.
Controversies are to be decided by the high priest and council, whose sentence must be obeyed, under pain of death. The duty
of a king, who is to receive the law of God at the priest's hands.
1 Thou *shalt not sacrifice to the Lord thy God a sheep, or an ox, wherein
there is blemish, or any fault: for that is an abomination to the Lord thy God.
2 When there shall be found among you, within any of thy gates, which
the Lord thy God shall give thee, man or woman that do evil in the sight of the Lord thy God, and transgress his covenant,
3 So as to go and serve strange gods, and adore them, the sun and the
moon, and all the host of heaven, which I have not commanded:
4 And this is told thee, and hearing it thou hast enquired diligently,
and found it to be true, and that the abomination is committed in Israel:
5 Thou shalt bring forth the man or the woman, who have committed that
most wicked thing, to the gates of thy city, and they shall be stoned.
6 *By the mouth of two, or three witnesses, shall he die that is to be
slain. Let no man be put to death, when only one beareth witness against him.
7 The hands of the witnesses shall be first upon him to kill him, *and
afterwards the hands of the rest of the people; that thou mayst take away the evil out of the midst of thee.
8 If thou perceive that there be among you a hard and doubtful matter
in judgment between blood and blood, cause and cause, leprosy and leprosy, and thou see that the words of the judges within
thy gates do vary: arise and go up to the place, which the Lord thy God shall choose:
9 *And thou shalt come to the priests of the Levitical race, and to the
judge, that shall be at that time: and thou shalt ask of them, and they shall shew thee the truth of the judgment.
10 And thou shalt do whatsoever they shall say, that preside in the place,
which the Lord shall choose, and what they shall teach thee,
11 According to his law: and thou shalt follow their sentence; neither
shalt thou decline to the right hand nor to the left hand.
12 But he that will be proud, and refuse to obey the commandment of the
priest, who ministereth at that time to the Lord thy God, and the decree of the judge, that man shall die, and thou shalt
take away the evil from Israel:
13 And all the people hearing it shall fear, that no one afterwards swell
14 When thou art come into the land, which the Lord thy God will give
thee, and possessest it, and dwellest in it, and shalt say: I will set a king over me, as all nations have that are round
15 Thou shalt set him, whom the Lord thy God shall choose out of the
number of thy brethren. Thou mayst not make a man of another nation king, that is not thy brother.
16 And when he is made king, he shall not multiply horses to himself,
nor lead back the people into Egypt, being lifted up with the number of his horsemen, especially since the Lord hath commanded
you to return no more the same way.
17 He shall not have many wives, that may allure his mind, nor immense
sums of silver and gold.
18 But after he is raised to the throne of his kingdom, he shall copy
out to himself the Deuteronomy of this law in a volume, taking the copy of the priests of the Levitical tribe,
19 And he shall have it with him, and shall read it all the days of his
life, that he may learn to fear the Lord his God, and keep his words and ceremonies, that are commanded in the law,
20 And that his heart be not lifted up with pride over his brethren,
nor decline to the right or to the left, that he and his sons may reign a long time over Israel.
1: Year of the World 2553.
6: Deuteronomy xix. 15.; Matthew xviii. 6.; 2 Corinthians xiii. 1.
7: Deuteronomy xiii. 9.
9: 2 Paralipomenon xix. 8.