Notes & Commentary:
Ver. 1. An
angel. Taking the shape of a man, (Challoner) such as had appeared to Josue, (chap. v. 13.; Menochius) the guardian angel
of Israel. (Haydock) --- The Jews commonly suppose that it was Phinees, the high priest, Malachias ii. 8. (Drusius)
But he might be dead with the rest of the ancients when this took place, as the Israelites seem to have experienced many difficulties
in consequence of their repeated prevarications, before this messenger was sent to them. He might very probably be some prophet,
who speaks in the name of God, (Aggeus i. 13,) as he is said to come not from heaven, but from Galgal to the place of weepers.
Hebrew, at Habbocim, "the mulberry trees." Septuagint, Klauthmon. This place, the valley of tears, (Psalm
lxxxiii. 7,) perhaps received his name afterwards, from what happened, ver. 4. Some suppose it designates Silo, where the
people might be assembled on some great festival, and where sacrifice was offered, ver. 5. Bonfrere collects from the Septuagint
and Josephus, ([Antiquities?] vii. 4,) that it lay beyond the vale of the Raphaim, on the south side of Jerusalem, (Menochius)
where this messenger might summon the people together, and authorize them to offer sacrifice, as was frequently done (Calmet)
by dispensation (Haydock) at a distance from the tabernacle, chap. vi. 20., and xiii. 19. --- I made. If he was an
angel, his authority could not be called in question; and if he was the high priest, or a prophet known to the people, they
would hear him with attention and respect. (Calmet) --- He appeared at least in human form, and spoke in the name of God.
(Worthington) (Josue v.)
Ver. 2. League.
None of a public nature had been perhaps made by the whole nation, to sanction the idolatry of the Chanaanites. But so many
individuals had entered into marriages with them and imitated their perverse manners, so many tribes had spared the cities,
&c., that the Israelites in general merited the reprimand. Whether these leagues, made in contradiction to God's command,
were to be observed or broken, is a matter of dispute. We may steer a middle course, and assert that such agreements as stipulated
the protection of the idolatrous worship and altars, were null, and never to be observed; whereas those which secured
to the inhabitants their lives and property, could not be lawfully broken, though the contractors did wrong in making such
leagues. See 1 Esdras ix. (Calmet)
Ver. 3. Ruin.
Septuagint, "stumbling block," the occasion of ruin. (Menochius) --- Thus by a false compassion (Calmet) and negligence, the
Israelites brought upon themselves the most serious difficulties, while those whom they had spared, turned against them by
a just judgment of God, and proved the ruin both of their souls and bodies, by drawing them into idolatry and then putting
them to the sword. (Haydock)
Ver. 5. Lord:
holocausts to acknowledge his dominion, and sacrifices of expiation for the transgressions of the people. Only the tabernacle
and temple were appointed for such sacrifices, though they might be offered elsewhere by dispensation. (St. Augustine, q.
Ver. 6. And
Josue, &c. This is here inserted out of Josue, (xxiv.) by way of recapitulation of what had happened before, and by
way of an introduction to that which follows. (Challoner) --- The sacred penman gives a short description of the general conduct
of the Israelites, shewing how they abandoned their former fidelity, after Josue and the elders were no more, and in consequence
were severely punished. Upon their repentance, God shewed them mercy again and again, as will be explained more at large (Haydock)
in the subsequent chapters. Salien and some others have hence inferred, that Josue was living when the angel made this reproach.
(Calmet) --- But that is contradicted by many passages in the Book of Josue, where the fidelity of the people is commended,
as well as here, ver. 7; and chap. i., we read of the death of Josue, so that St. Augustine (q. 14,) says, "there can be no
doubt but this is a recapitulation." (Menochius) --- As little had been said before, to enable us to see the grounds of the
accusation, these few remarks are subjoined to justify the words of the angel, who appeared while the people was groaning
under the afflictions which their sins had deserved. (Calmet)
Ver. 10. Fathers.
These expressions prove the immortality of the soul, Job xxxiv. 4., &c. Knew not, or did not approve or cordially
serve the Lord. His tabernacle was still at Silo. But many joined the worship of idols with that of the true God, (Calmet)
and light and darkness can never agree. (Haydock)
Ver. 12. They
followed strange gods. What is here said of the children of Israel, as to their falling so often into idolatry, is to
be understood of a great part of them; but not so universally, as if the true worship of God was ever quite abolished among
them: for the succession of the true church and religion was kept up all this time by the priest and Levites, at least in
the house of God in Silo. (Challoner) --- At different times God raised up deliverers, who were taken from among his people,
and no doubt abhorred the impiety of the multitude.
Ver. 13. Baal,
"Lord," a title given to many of the idols, (Haydock) both male and female. (Menochius) --- They are often distinguished by
some additional name, as Beelzebub, "fly," and berith, "covenant," gods adored at Accaron and Sichem. Under
this name the pagans adored heaven or the sun, (Calmet) as Astaroth denoted some female deity, the moon, Venus, &c. (Menochius)
Ver. 14. Who
took. Hebrew, "that spoiled them, and he sold" or abandoned them, &c. (Calmet)
Ver. 16. Them,
for any long time. Their inconstancy was astonishing. (Haydock) --- These judges raised up by God, or chose by the
people under his direction, often rescued Israel from servitude; and during the remainder of their lives, watched to see the
laws put in execution, being assisted by the counsels of the senators (Menochius) and magistrates of the nation. (Haydock)
--- They were commissioned to rescue the penitent and suffering Israelites. (Worthington)
Ver. 17. Quickly.
They had persevered in virtue under the government of Josue and of the elders, for the space of forty years, according to
Marsham and Houbigant. The former places the first state of anarchy and of idolatry 34 years after Josue, allowing 15 years
for the administration of the surviving ancients, and the remainder to bring the nation to such a pitch of wickedness as to
force God to abandon it to the dominion of Chusan, for eight years. --- Walked. Hebrew and Septuagint, "walked, obeying
the commands of the Lord: they did not so."
Ver. 18. Moved,
&c. Hebrew and Septuagint, "and the Lord was with the judge, and delivered them out of the hand of their enemies all the
days of the judge, (for it repented the Lord (Septuagint, he was moved to compassion) on account of their groans, &c.)
(Haydock) --- The repentance of God denotes a change of conduct in our regard. (Calmet) --- Delivered. Hence the judges
have the title of Saviour, chap. iii. 9., and 2 Esdras ix. 27. (Menochius)
Ver. 19. And
did. Hebrew, "and corrupted themselves." Septuagint, "were more depraved than," &c. --- By which, &c.,
is put instead of the Hebrew, "their stubborn (or hard) (Haydock) Chaldean, 'corrupt' way." This hard and rough path denotes
the labours which the wicked have to encounter, in the pursuit of pleasure, as they themselves confess. We wearied ourselves
in the way of iniquity....and have walked through hard ways, Wisdom v. 7. (Calmet) --- Though the life of the libertine
seem delightful, it draws on the most serious evils and provokes the anger of God. (Menochius)
Ver. 21. Nations.
Hebrew, "any." Septuagint, "a man of those nations," which must be understood, unless the Israelites return to a proper sense
of their duty. For then he destroyed not only individuals, but whole armies, by the hand of the judges. Yet we do not find
that such havoc was made among the infidels afterwards, as had been made in the days of Josue. They frequently rose up and
harassed the Israelites; and God suffered them to do so, that the latter might learn to know themselves, and might perceive
how dreadful a thing it is not to comply, at first, with his injunctions. (Haydock)
Ver. 22. Or
not. The secrets of hearts cannot be hidden from the omniscience of God. (Calmet) --- But he would have an experimental
knowledge of the fidelity of his people, by leaving these nations in the midst of them. It was partly on this account that
he withdrew the sword of Josue, who would otherwise have easily followed up his victories, and exterminated all the inhabitants.
The cowardice and secret indispositions of the people was another obstacle. (Haydock) --- God acted like a person who distrusted
the fidelity of his servant, and left something in his way to see if we would steal it. (Calmet)
Bible Text & Cross-references:
An angel reproveth Israel. They weep for their sins. After
the death of Josue, they often fall, and repenting, are delivered from their afflictions; but still fall worse and worse.
1 And an angel of the Lord went up from Galgal to the place of weepers,
and said: I made you go out of Egypt, and have brought you into the land for which I swore to your fathers: and I promised
that I would not make void my covenant with you for ever:
2 On condition that you should not make a league with the inhabitants of
this land, but should throw down their altars: and you would not hear my voice: why have you done this?
3 Wherefore I would not destroy them from before your face; that you may
have enemies, and their gods may be your ruin.
4 And when the angel of the Lord spoke these words to all the children
of Israel: they lifted up their voice, and wept.
5 And the name of that place was called, The place of weepers, or of tears:
and there they offered sacrifices to the Lord.
6 *And Josue sent away the people, and the children of Israel went every
one to his own possession to hold it:
7 And they served the Lord all his days, and the days of the ancients,
that lived a long time after him, and who knew all the works of the Lord, which he had done for Israel.
8 And Josue, the son of Nun, the servant of the Lord, died, being a hundred
and ten years old;
9 And they buried him in the borders of his possession in Thamnathsare,
in Mount Ephraim, on the north side of Mount Gaas.
10 And all that generation was gathered to their fathers: and there arose
others that knew not the Lord, and the works which he had done for Israel.
11 And the children of Israel did evil in the sight of the Lord, and they
12 And they left the Lord, the God of their fathers, who had brought them
out of the land of Egypt: and they followed strange gods, and the gods of the people that dwelt round about them, and they
adored them: and they provoked the Lord to anger,
13 Forsaking him, and serving Baal and Astaroth.
14 And the Lord being angry against Israel, delivered them into the hands
of plunderers: who took them and sold them to their enemies, that dwelt round about: neither could they stand against their
15 But whithersoever they meant to go, the hand of the Lord was upon them,
as he had said, and as he had sworn to them: and they were greatly distressed.
16 And the Lord raised up judges, to deliver them from the hands of those
that oppressed them: but they would not hearken to them,
17 Committing fornication with strange gods, and adoring them. They quickly
forsook the way, in which their fathers had walked: and hearing the commandments of the Lord, they did all things contrary.
18 And when the Lord raised them up judges, in their days, he was moved
to mercy, and heard the groanings of the afflicted, and delivered them from the slaughter of the oppressors.
19 But after the judge was dead, they returned, and did much worse things
than their fathers had done, following strange gods, serving them, and adoring them. They left not their own inventions, and
the stubborn way, by which they were accustomed to walk.
20 And the wrath of the Lord was kindled against Israel, and he said: Behold
this nation hath made void my covenant, which I had made with their fathers, and hath despised to hearken to my voice:
21 I also will not destroy the nations which Josue left when he died:
22 That through them I may try Israel, whether they will keep the way of
the Lord, and walk in it, as their fathers kept it, or not.
23 The Lord therefore left all these nations, and would not quickly destroy
them, neither did he deliver them into the hands of Josue.
6: Josue xxiv. 28.