1 Kings vi.
Notes & Commentary:
Diviners. The priests generally pretended to a knowledge of magic, among the pagans. (Calmet)
If, &c. The lords were already determined to send back the ark. But the priests knew that some still would not
believe that it was the cause of their affliction. To convince all, they try an experiment, which would decide the matter;
and in case the ark went back, some suitable presents must accompany it, as a propitiation (Haydock) for the sin which they
would not (Menochius) then doubt had been incurred. (Haydock) --- Though God stands in need of nothing, all must acknowledge
their dependence on him. The pagans always made some present, when they appeared before their idols or monarchs, and God requires
the like testimony of submission, Exodus xxiii. 15.
Provinces. Hebrew seranim, "lords." --- Emerods. Theodoret observes, that the tombs of the martyrs were
adorned with figures of eyes, &c., in gratitude for their having procured redress for the afflicted. --- Israel,
whose ark you have treated in an improper manner. (Calmet) --- You shall thus confess that He chastises, and grants health.
(Menochius) --- Gods. Not only Dagon, but the other idols, were humbled, (Haydock) though the Hebrew word denotes also
one god, or princes, &c.
Hearts. Even these confess that obduracy proceeds from men; (Worthington) though Calvin would make God the author of
New cart. It would have been deemed irreverent to use one that had been employed for other profane purposes, 2 Kings
vi. 3. --- Home. All these circumstances tended to prevent the ark from being conveyed home, (Calmet) unless Providence
Box. Hebrew argaz, (which the Septuagint retain; Haydock) means also "a purse or basket." (Calmet) --- Josephus
([Antiquities?] vi. 1,) says, "the box was placed upon the ark." (Haydock) --- We do not read what became of these presents
afterwards: but it is supposed that they were kept in the sanctuary till the time of the captivity. (Calmet)
Way. Josephus observes, that they stationed the kine at three lane ends; (Haydock) and, as we may infer from the Hebrew
(ver. 12,) rather with their heads turned from Bethsames. But, by this conduct, did they not tempt God? Some believe that
He inspired them on this occasion, (Estius) that even his enemies might be convinced, (Haydock) the grace of prophecy being
frequently granted to wicked men, like Balaam: others believe that He gave success to their plan, though it was dictated by
superstition. Even the devil sometimes speaks the truth. (Mendoza) (Calmet) --- People frequently use to pitch upon signs,
to which God often assented, Proverbs xvi. 33., (Menochius) and Genesis xxiv. 14. (Haydock)
Wheat, about Pentecost, in May; so that the ark must have been taken in November. (Menochius)
Bethsamite, not the renowned general. (Calmet) --- Stone, which served instead of an altar. (Menochius) ---
Lord. Some pretend that the lords of the Philistines followed so far, and offered this holocaust, as the cart belonged
to them: but the Bethsamites might suppose that they had abandoned their property, as well as the golden figures; and, as
the city belonged to the priests, it is most probable that they would perform this office. Males indeed were to be offered
in the tabernacle. But this was an extraordinary case; so that, if there were no priests, the sacrifice might be lawful (Calmet)
by dispensation, as we see Samuel and Elias did the like. (Haydock) --- The kine and cart being consecrated to God, it was
thought that they could not be turned to a more suitable purpose. (Calmet) --- The ark was also present, on account of which,
sacrifices were offered in the tabernacle. The arguments of Abulensis, (q. 19,) who accuses the Bethsamites of sin on this
account, are not therefore satisfactory. (Menochius)
Vessels. Protestants less properly, "jewels of gold." (Haydock)
Day. It was distant about 18 miles. (Calmet) --- Provinces. Hebrew, "lords." Some think that only five images
of each sort were inclosed in the box: others suppose that the people of each village presented a golden mouse, to satisfy
their own devotion, and that they might not be infested with such vermin. Clarius thinks they also sent an equal number of
the other images of the anus, chap. v. (Haydock)
Abel. A stone or rock, on which the Jews say Abraham had offered sacrifice; (St. Jerome, Trad. T.[Tirinus?]) Hebrew,
"or mourning," was so called afterwards, on account of so many being slain; (Menochius) so the place, to which the Egyptians
accompanied the remains of Jacob, was styled "Abol," the mourning of Egypt, Genesis l. 11. (Haydock) --- The Septuagint
read Abon, "the stone." All the towns belonging to the Philistines, as far as this place, sent each their golden images,
or contributed towards those which were presented by the five lords. --- Which, ark, according to the Vulgate, though
some would explain it of the stone. The ark might remain here for some time, and would probably have continued longer, if
the people had not been so much afflicted. In the mean time, this record may have been written, as it was afterwards inserted
in this book. (Calmet) --- Which, though of the feminine gender, is referred to stone, because Abol is of that description,
(Menochius) and we find several such allusions to the Hebrew in our version. Protestants, "unto the great stone of
Abel, whereon they set down the ark of the Lord, which stone remaineth unto this day," &c. (Haydock; Vatable, &c.)
--- Others think that the ark remained there till it was removed to Cariathiarim, chap. vii. 1. Malvenda says, the memory
of the transaction was fresh till the author wrote; while others maintain, that the golden figures continued with the ark
till that time. (Calmet) --- The Roman Septuagint omits the words till this day; and reads, "where they placed upon
it (the stone) the ark....upon the stone in the field," &c. Then with the Alexandrian copy, and Procopius, &c., it
subjoins 19. "And the sons of Jechonias did not approve, among the men of Bethsames, that they saw the ark of the Lord, and
he slew of them 70 men, and 50,000 of the people." Theodoret suspects that they were more impious than the rest. But we might
as well say that they shewed more (Calmet) reverence, as we may explain slew of them, to denote the two curious citizens,
(Haydock) if any dependence could be had on this addition. (Calmet)
Seen; and curiously looked into. It is likely this plague reached to all the neighbouring country, as well as the city
of Bethsames. (Challoner) --- For we need not suppose that all these deaths took place in one day. The ark seems to have continued
there for some time, ver. 18. Hebrew, "because they had looked into, or at the ark." (Haydock) --- It was unlawful,
even for the Levites, to touch or to look at the ark uncovered; (Tirinus; Numbers iv. 15, 20,) and the Hebrew expression
into, is often taken in this sense, Proverbs vii. 15., and xi. 4. --- Men of rank. (St. Gregory, &c.) "Ancients,"
Chaldean. Some would suppose that only these 70 perished, and were of as much value as 50,000 of the common people: for they
will not allow that the latter number was slain. Out of that number, 70 were made victims of the divine justice. (Tirinus;
Sa) --- Bochart translates, "he slew 70 out of 50,000." The Syriac and Arabic read, "5070 men." Josephus only admits 70 who
were slain, "because they dared to touch the ark with their profane hands, as they were not priests." Hebrew, "and he slew
of the people 70 men, 50,000 men. (Calmet) --- Kennicott seems to suspect that a cipher has been added in the Hebrew at the
end. Protestants, "50,000, and threescore and ten men." (Haydock) --- Some would insert aderant in the Vulgate, and
50,000 "were present." (Du Hamel) --- The Chaldean, Septuagint, &c., constantly retain these numbers, and we must not
judge of God severity by our feeble reason. (Calmet) --- This decision is the most common. (Menochius) --- The people had
indulged their curiosity, to see whether the Philistines had taken the tables of the law out of the ark, &c. (Serarius)
--- As the ark was terrible to the infidels, so it was also to those true believers, who treated it with disrespect. (Worthington)
Us. These words may denote that they thought God too severe, or else, that they judged themselves unworthy of his presence.
There is no proportion between an offence of God, and what the creature can do to make him satisfaction. (Calmet)
Up. This is the import of the Hebrew. The Vulgate reducite, "bring it back," insinuates, that the Bethsamites
desired the people of Cariathiarim to convey the ark to their city, on the road to Silo, where they probably thought it ought
to be placed, in the tabernacle. But it seems God ordered it otherwise, and the ark was never restored to its former splendid
station, surrounded with all the vessels and ornaments of the tabernacle. David made something similar, and place an altar
before it, while the Mosaic tabernacle and altar were removed from Silo to Nobe, (chap. xxi. 1.) and afterwards to Gabaon,
2 Paralipomenon i. 5. Salien (the year of the world 3030) doubts not but they were thence translated to Solomon's temple,
during the octave of the dedication, along with those of David, from Mount Sion, 2 Paralipomenon v. 2., and viii. 3. Why the
ark was not placed in this most magnificent abode, but removed from the stone of Abel to the houses of Abinadab, of Obededom,
of David in Sion, till all the original ornaments, prescribed by God to Moses, with a still more splendid apparatus, met to
adorn the temple of Solomon, we cannot easily explain. Perhaps it might be to render that event more glorious, and to represent
the troubled state of the Jewish Synagogue, immediately preceding the appearance of the great Redeemer, who would establish
a church without spot or wrinkle, shining brighter than the sun, and replenished with all heavenly graces. (Haydock) --- Cariathiarim
is the same place as Cariathbaal, and Baala, (Josue xv. 9, 60.) Baalim Juda, (2 Kings vi. 2.) and Sedeiarim, about ten miles
from Jerusalem. Gabaa was "a hill," (Calmet) belonging to the same city, where the house of Abinadab stood; (Haydock) and
Nobe was also in the vicinity, while Silo was much farther north. (Calmet) --- The priests still remained, and offered sacrifice
in the tabernacle, though occasionally some of them might come to offer extraordinary victims before the ark, in those private
houses which were thus converted, as it were, into the holy of holies. Salien, the year of the world 2941, where he observes
from St. Jerome, that the tabernacle was removed to Nobe about the same time as the ark was deposited at Cariathiarim; and
no doubt both the translations were in consequence of the divine command, signified by the mouth of his prophet Samuel. (Haydock)
Bible Text & Cross-references:
The ark is sent back to Bethsames: where many are slain
for looking through curiosity into it.
1 Now *the ark of God was in the land of the Philistines seven months.
2 And the Philistines called for the priests and the diviners, saying:
What shall we do with the ark of the Lord? tell us how we are to send it back to its place? And they said:
3 If you send back the ark of the God of Israel, send it not away empty,
but render unto him what you owe for sin, and then you shall be healed: and you shall know why his hand departeth not from
4 They answered: What is it we ought to render unto him for sin? and
5 According to the number of the provinces of the Philistines you shall
make five golden emerods, and five golden mice: for the same plague hath been upon you all, and upon your lords. And you shall
make the likeness of your emerods, and the likeness of the mice, that have destroyed the land, and you shall give glory to
the God of Israel: to see if he will take off his hand from you, and from your gods, and from your land.
6 Why do you harden your hearts, as Egypt and Pharao hardened their hearts?
*did not he, after he was struck, then let them go, and they departed?
7 Now, therefore, take and make a new cart: and two kine that have calved,
on which there hath come no yoke, tie to the cart, and shut up their calves at home.
8 And you shall take the ark of the Lord, and lay it on the cart, and
the vessels of gold, which you have paid him for sin, you shall put into a little box at the side thereof: and send it away,
that it may go.
9 And you shall look: and if it go up by the way of his own coasts, towards
Bethsames, then he hath done us this great evil: but if not, we shall know that it is not his hand hath touched us, but it
hath happened by chance.
10 They did therefore in this manner: and taking two kine, that had suckling
calves, they yoked them to the cart, and shut up their calves at home.
11 And they laid the ark of God upon the cart, and the little box that
had in it the golden mice, and the likeness of the emerods.
12 And the kine took the straight way, that leadeth to Bethsames, and
they went along the way, lowing as they went: and turned not aside neither to the right hand nor to the left: and the lords
of the Philistines followed them as far as the borders of Bethsames.
13 Now the Bethsamites were reaping wheat in the valley: and lifting
up their eyes, they saw the ark, and rejoiced to see it.
14 And the cart came into the field of Josue, a Bethsamite, and stood
there. And there was a great stone, and they cut in pieces the wood of the cart, and laid the kine upon it a holocaust to
15 And the Levites took down the ark of God, and the little box that
was at the side of it, wherein were the vessels of gold, and they put them upon the great stone. The men also of Bethsames
offered holocausts, and sacrificed victims that day to the Lord.
16 And the five princes of the Philistines saw, and they returned to
Accaron the same day.
17 And these are the golden emerods, which the Philistines returned for
sin to the Lord: For Azotus one, for Gaza one, for Ascalon one, for Geth one, for Accaron one:
18 And the golden mice, according to the number of the cities of the
Philistines, of the five provinces, from the fenced city to the village that was without wall, and to the great Abel (the
stone) whereon they set down the ark of the Lord, which was till that day in the field of Josue the Bethsamite.
19 But he slew of the men of Bethsames, because they had seen the ark
of the Lord, and he slew of the people seventy men, and fifty thousand of the common people. And the people lamented, because
the Lord had smitten the people with a great slaughter.
20 And the men of Bethsames said: Who shall be able to stand before the
Lord this holy God? and to whom shall he go up from us?
21 And they sent messengers to the inhabitants of Cariathiarim, saying:
The Philistines have brought back the ark of the Lord, come ye down and fetch it up to you.
1: Year of the World 2888.
6: Exodus xii. 31.